Poverty is relative…Mozambique is a poor country, rated by some experts as one of the 10 poorest in the world. People we meet here talk about being poor but for the most part, the people we come in the most direct contact are well fed (because they grow their own food in their fields) but may not have enough money to have super nice clothes (but their clothes are clean) or a house made of cement (but many have tin roofs on sun-baked brick houses). Many adults are taking advantage of educational opportunities available for adults to continue their education that might have been cut short because of the war, early marriage, the need to work in their family’s fields or other life events. They may not have a lot of money to put into the offering plate on Sunday but they seem to be happy—surrounded by their families and friends, living their lives. In a discussion about poverty during our MCC orientation, the presenter, a former director of Ten Thousand Villages challenged us to look at what poor people do to generate income. We daily see people making a living with small business ventures—cutting hair, selling fruits and vegetables by the road, selling clothing on sidewalks, baking little cakes and selling them, collecting money on the chopa (mini bus), or buying live animals, butchering them and then selling the meat.
What does poverty really mean? I read once that poverty is a lack of options. That certainly seems to resonate here. Each place we visit seems to be lacking something—good roads, adequate rainfall, adequate building materials, transportation, food, education. Each group of people we come into contact with us tells us that they are poor. It seems to be a chronic condition here. But what I am learning is how we all interpret our own poverty (generally economic) differently. One person may say that he/she is poor because he/she can not afford really nice clothes, while another can barely afford the chopa fare to the next town but has enough to eat, while another lacks access to clean water. For each person who says he/she is poor, it seems like there are others lacking more than he/she. I am challenged to rethink all the times I considered myself poor—was I truly lacking when I was in graduate school?
In the midst of all this, we see so much hope. We see Mozambican society working to make a difference in itself. All over there are signs of support for those who are affected by HIV/AIDS. On World AIDS Day, students wore shirts and participated in marches to educate the public more about HIV/AIDS. Municipalities are fixing roads—filling in potholes, repaving streets, paving side walks. We see public gardens being maintained—weeded, new plants germinated, trees trimmed, parks landscaped, tree trunks painted. Every morning individuals sweep their section of the sidewalk next to a street and their yards. We know quite a few people who are going to school. Women are attending school and some are learning how to drive. Many people have radios (even those who do not have electricity, have a battery operated radio) and regularly listen to it. (We get our news through our friends in the church!) They know a bit about the world and current events. They know what is happening in their own country. Immediately after the flooding of the Zambezi river, a call was put out to churches to help with relief materials. People gave, albeit it was not much, but they did give to help others.
Now as we are working in the Distrito de Mandie (Mandie District – pronounced man dee a) with the sand dam project, we are given yet another glimpse into what poverty is. I hear people in Gondola and Chimoio toss around the phrase, “absolute poverty” as a description for their condition. It’s a phrase I heard in graduate school and it seemed a good description at that time. Now that I live here in Mozambique, I’m not quite sure I like the term. Yes, it does describe some of the conditions that people experience on a daily basis but it is a very negative term. It lacks dignity and sometimes is trapping, as if when people use the phrase to describe to themselves, they have given up. While I was working for DOOR, I heard of a story that a child had hung out with a group of volunteers and enjoyed himself. He didn’t notice the economic differences between them until the last day and someone said something about poor people. He didn’t know that he was poor until that moment and it suddenly separated him from the people he had come to love and respect. Hearing from them that he was poor suddenly took away his dignity and said that something was lacking in his life when before he wasn’t lacking.
I’m not saying that people here are not poor, but I wonder about the words we use to describe. How can we describe poverty that shows people’s dignity? When we asked the communities that we are considering partnering with to build sand dams, what they would do with access to water, almost all of them said that they would use it to bathe, wash clothes, grow vegetables, and water their cattle. The sand dam project is designed for the communities to take ownership of the dam and eventually of the water that will come. For them, the potential of having water close by year round is an answer to prayer and I hope that their involvement in building and maintaining the dam will add to their dignity.
In the meantime, as we work with groups in Gondola and Chimoio that use the phrase “absolute poverty”, how do we not become trapped by the description, to not have it be a self-fulfilling prophesy but only a proscription, not a prescription? Not only for us who are outsiders working with communities but also for the communities themselves? As I wrote previously, I see many positive things happening and I think it is important to remind people of what they are doing and how they are not trapped by the phrase. It seems to me that people who are continually trying new things are moving, growing and taking risks to see the world in a new way, are battling the label.